Post-apocalyptic City tutorial assestment

Post-apocalyptic City tutorial assestment 

by

Milan Maric

Part 1:

Introduction into the tutorial is great, pretty easy to follow and the pictures help alot since the options hes applying are "selected" making it much easier. The more tricky or "complex" should i say executions are explained more in detail to the point where you could blindfoldly follow the tutorial. However one thing i reacted to was that he wasn't showing how his render options were setup at start, cause i tried to do the first part of the tutorial my self and i kept getting different resaults.
One thing thats nice was the part with "Partical View" where he explained basically what each option did or how it worked. I personally have barely touched the particle viewer yet i could easily follow up. Same as me he encountered problems which he adressed and provided the solutions each step of the way through the first part of the tutorial! 
This scene isn't that easy to make nor is it beginner friendly but this student did a great job at simplifying it down frankly there isnt much else to say for the first part other then job well done!

Part 2:

I didn't do part 2 since i don't have After Effects but same here as the first part complete followthrough throu the whole procedure to the point. One thing worth mentioning back at the ending of part one he was rendering out elements, i don't know how its on others 3dmax but i was missing some options for "render elements" and i can't see if he provided the support files for this. Anyways back to the AE part i notice straight away he was providing full screen screenshots which don't really help much, he should have zoomed in on the options and maybe even highlighted the options he was clicking on. I can't say much about part two but i imagine i'd get lost along the way. Nothing much else to say but overall it is a great tutorial which is easy to follow (atleast throught he part1) there were some parts that weren't so clear but nothing to fuss much about. In the end he also explains how you could increase the quality and the details if you feel like it, so yeah for a beginner im impressed!